Saturday, 9 February 2013

Who is your Sparta - A Democratic Note


There is a Spartan war to every Democracy. The question here is "Who is your Sparta?". 

Worlds first democracy began in 5th century BC,2500 years ago,lasted around 150 years,and was replaced by thousands of years of monarchies.This democracy of the New World is around 200 years old and some countries like India(60 years),Bhutan(5 years) are relatively new democracies. These systems of governance dont remain for long.They die out due to corruption,decadence,internal politics or something else.

When democracy was flourishing in Europe,the Great Depression alone amounted to the transit from democracies to dictatorships, examples being Nazi Germany(Hitler),fascist Italy(Mussolini),Spain etc.In countries like Pakistan,its democracy for few years followed by dictatorship for few with very less consistency.

It was only after Second World War that the most part of the world started  moving to the democratic model of governance.But is it that simple.And are all the democracies in the world similar,can they all be weighed in the same balance? Democratic nations vary widely internally in their structure.

There are direct democracies and hybrid democracies with both having further sub types.There are full democracies and flawed democracies.Do you know which type of a democracy your country is? India for example is a multi-party,parliamentary,representative democracy. And while only 25 countries are categorised as "full democracies", the Democracy Index 2011 puts India alongwith Sri Lanka,Italy,Israel,Argentina and 49 more countries as" flawed democracies".

The 20th Century Italian thinkers Vilfredo Pareto and Gaetano Mosca (independently) argued that

"Democracy was illusory, and served only to mask the reality of elite rule. Indeed, they argued that elite oligarchy is the unbendable law of human nature, due largely to the apathy and division of the masses , and that democratic institutions would do no more than shift the exercise of power from oppression to manipulation."

And its true most of the times,since no country is ideally democratic and the flaws they have in turn lead to manipulation of one set of people by the other.While the beginnings of democracies find roots in the fact that people wanted freedom from the nobility and aristocracy in the days of monarchy,the suffering of the common person have no way ended.If it was the "nobility" then, its the "families" or "dynasties" now. India for example has been ruled by the Gandhi family almost since its Independence from British rule. Three PMs from one family with Sonia Gandhi declining the offer once and Rahul Gandhi being groomed to become the next PM, that is, five Prime Ministerial prospects from a single family within 60 years. And the situation is no different in the regional governments. In fact its even worse,since they are not under international limelight.Pakistan has the Bhuttos,Bhutan has the Dorjis,Bangladesh has the Chawdhary family and theres a whole list called "Political families of the world" in Wikipedia.

In addition to the changing face of aristocracy in democratic countries,there are loopholes which can and are manipulated to favor some or oppress some. For example, theres a political process of gerrymandering called "cracking" which is to spread out a certain group ,which you dont want to have a say in the government, into different constituencies,eventually making them a clear minority in all constituencies and hence no representation.

The rulers in democracies do not have to satisfy any eligiblity criteria except for age while all the other government positions have clearly defined pre-requisites.Any one who is popular amongst the people can win and get elected.Examples being many celebrities.How a person who is only a great actor and has no previous political experience can satisfy the requirements of being a good statesperson. And people may even love jokers too.And then there are good people and bad people.Bad people want rulers who satisfy their requirements,good people want good rulers. People are emotional and not always rational and can even vote against their self interests.This point is further emphasied by every "opposition" party which in a
way is telling people "You did not make a rational choice,you chose something which is not good for you.You ,O people,made the wrong choice.So choose us the next time".

And thats why Israeli politician Rabbi Elazar Menachem Shach whilst promoting Judaic law to be the natural governance for Jews claimed that

"The whole point of democracy is money. The one does what the other asks him to do in pursuit of his own interest, so as to be given what he himself asks for, and the whole purpose of the transaction is that each would get what they want".

For example,at the hanging of a Kashmiri man over involvement in the attack at Indian Parliament,as I didnt post or tweet,I observed my Facebook and Twitter which showed contrasting views.People from Kashmir valley condemning the hanging citing unfair trial as the reason and people from  the rest of India mostly rejoicing citing justice as the reason. Now according to the democratic norms,if both of these groups were to choose their elected representive,the first group would never choose a candidate who agrees with the hanging,while the second group would never choose a candidate which sympathises with the hanged person. If Kashmiris go on and choose some separatist to be their representative,would their choice be a valid one,would it be a democratic one,would the rest of India agree to their democratic choice.And similarly,if the rest of India chooses some right wing extremist ,would their choice be valid. Thus this assumption of democracy,that every choice made by every citizen is the right,most perfect choice for him or her is a somewhat flawed assumption. What Im trying to say is not in anyway anti-egalitarian .People are equal in rights but not in the mental abililty of making the most perfect choice.An 18 year old teenager could even vote for Justin Beiber if not guided properly.

The search for the best system of governance doesnt end with democracy. The search for the thinking mind begins here.

And the question here is for every person to answer for himself. Like the Spartan war ended the Athenian democracy,could there be a Sparta for your democracy and if yes then who or what could be your Sparta? 



Nabeel Kamili